l prefer a used silver/gray in great condition.If not where can l find great deals on new ones.Need specific place not just a website to spend hours trying to find part.
Will just a Subaru Impreza fender fit?
l am looking for after market prices.l have checked every junk yard. No luck.

Reading your question l know that you do not want to pay dealers prices. Try your local junk yard.

Try the website below for good prices on new parts.

this is a usually a dealer item only.
sometimes body shops will carry this sort of part, but not usually.
like this place, http://levangroup.com/
but if u cant find it in a junk yard or on ebay or craigslist,
then it may not be anywhere,

a good body shop can fix things like that without u having to find the part.

l have a 2002 WRX & the metal is really thin, its good for high gas mileage & fast acceleration, but bad for long term survival of used body parts, u might have to go to the subaru dealer for a new one.

Newby drivers total WRX is every other day, there has to be a fender at a junkyard somewhere.

If you have a sedan wrx you will need a sedan fender, they are different from the wagons. That is why a lot of people do a sedan front end conversion on thier wagons.

Otherwise go to a wholesaler and get an unpainted fender ~$150 and have a shop paint match it if you cant find a junker.

Try Nasioc in the f/s threads. People have part outs going on all the time from wrecked WRXs. It takes a little bit of time to find what u want, but it is easier than driving around to junkyards, & there is plenty of new stuff added daily.

If new, expect to pay around $140 plus s&h for the fender, then painting on top of that. Painting for one piece wo not be that bad, cost wise. l use subarugenuineparts.com/ for OEM parts when l can not find them on Nasioc. Jamie is a great help.

Also, as someone pointed out above, sedan & wagon fenders r different.